Earlier this year, my colleagues and I at Johns Hopkins University did something all too rare in the world of higher education: We actually brought down the cost of a degree.
At the time, U.S. graduate schools were projecting fall enrollment declines of up to 30%. Administrators and faculty I spoke with were resigned to budget cuts, or worse.
Fortunately, the master’s program in public management that I direct and co-founded 15 years ago was undergoing a redesign. We decided to increase the number of required courses — to ensure students learned skills they needed to excel in the workplace — and reduce the number of electives, targeting them to one of three specializations. While it wasn’t our primary focus, the result was that students could now complete the program with fewer courses and credits. The total cost of our degree fell by just over $10,000.
Lo and behold, student interest rebounded. Prior to the announcement, fall signups were projected to decline by more than half. But shortly after we debuted the new degree requirements, enrollments bounced back. Our final class was just a handful of students smaller than the previous year.
We are, of course, just one small master’s program. But efforts like ours show that students will reward schools that find ways to lower costs without compromising academic rigor. In an era of shrinking student bodies and tight budgets, offering better value may in fact be the only way many colleges and universities can survive.
Higher education today faces structural, long-term challenges because enrollment is heading for a generational decline. The number of high school graduates has already peaked, and by 2041 will be 13% lower than today. The number of new international students, which collapsed by 17% last year, will likely continue to drop as the quality of universities in China, India, and elsewhere continues to improve.
In the past, schools could always boost enrollment and revenues by creating new degree programs. No longer. Asking a student with $30,220 in student loans (the current average per undergraduate borrower) to take out another $100,000 for graduate school, or to earn a certificate, is akin to asking a runner who has just completed a marathon to do it again in an hour.
Some colleges, especially small private institutions, are already struggling financially because of enrollment challenges, leading presidents to respond with across-the-board cuts. But this approach will do more harm than good over the long term, since it hits high-value investments and wasteful spending alike. Much like American automakers in the 1970s and ’80s, schools will end up hurting the quality of their product, especially if they cut programs that are core to the institution’s mission or that are major revenue earners.
Schools would be better served by trying to become more efficient, capable of delivering the same, or even better, educational outcomes for less money. To do so, faculty and administrators need to work with students to determine what parts of the educational experience are a priority, and what aren’t. Schools should ideally get back to basics by focusing on teaching and research, rather than services such as “life design” (one of the many new names for what used to be called career services), student government, and the other offices and programs dedicated to the “student experience.”
Furthermore, schools need to take a serious look at the rise in administrative bloat. America’s 50 best colleges now have three times as many administrative and professional staff as faculty. On average, private nonprofit schools spend slightly more on administration than on teaching.
Institutions should then pass on their savings from more efficient operations to students in the form of lower tuition. Schools that lead the way will increase the pool of individuals able and willing to go to college or graduate school. We know this because the biggest barrier to entering and completing college is price.
Some institutions have begun taking the sorts of dramatic steps necessary to provide better value. For instance, three-year degree programs — an idea PPI has long advocated — appear to be rapidly gaining traction. Starting in fall 2027, New York University will offer a redesigned undergraduate nursing program that can be completed in three years and will save students around $100,000 in tuition, fees, and living expenses. The states of Ohio, Virginia, and Massachusetts this year approved programs that allow students to earn a four-year degree in three years by reducing the number of credits required to graduate from the standard 120 credits to roughly 90 credits.
Unfortunately, most college presidents aren’t yet bold enough to undertake serious reforms aimed at lowering costs. Many are convinced that dropping prices will inevitably lead to lower revenue, when in fact the opposite can be true. Others still follow the decades-old dictum that “price equates to quality.” Administrators and faculty may also oppose cuts that threaten jobs.
But if colleges and universities don’t move on their own, the federal government could push them in the right direction. While deeply misguided, President Donald Trump’s assault on academia has proven that Washington has tremendous leverage over colleges and universities. Instead of wasting this influence sowing division and pursuing personal vendettas, the government should use it to encourage schools to reduce the price of earning a degree.
Universities should also be rewarded for innovations such as redesigning degrees and majors to allow students to graduate in less than four years, making the transition from community college to four-year programs seamless, and ensuring colleges grant credit for college courses taken in high school and successful completion of Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate studies.
Ultimately, institutions of higher learning must adapt quickly and strategically to the new economic reality. College presidents will have to make tough choices, and some faculty, administrators, and students will resist. But in the long run, the only way to attract more students will be to offer them a truly better deal.





Passing savings along to students is typically the last thing universities opt to do. In nearly 30 years of teaching, I’ve never seen it happen. There are many possible explanations, but two come to mind. The first concerns student representation. In Germany, student unions are directly involved, formally and informally, in debates over tuition. Efforts to increase what students pay often meet organized opposition from the very people who would bear the cost. Student unions and student governance in Germany play an actual role in university governance.
By contrast, at American universities, students often have little meaningful involvement in decisions about tuition and fees. When disputes arise over funding IT, wellness centers, study abroad programs, administrative initiatives, or additional advising, the compromise is often to add a student fee or assume future tuition increases will cover the expense. Students and parents—the people paying the bill—are rarely in the room to object. Not surprisingly, costs and fees keep rising.
The second explanation concerns inequality within higher education. Wealthy institutions with large, tax-free endowments can bid up compensation in ways that put pressure on other universities to follow. Ron Daniels, President of Hopkins and Perlioni Jason, former Hopkins CIO pull in nearly $5 million per year each. When presidents, provosts, associate provosts, and deans at the wealthiest schools receive record salaries, those salaries become benchmarks elsewhere.
The result is a kind of rising tide in compensation, driven by institutions with resources most universities cannot match. Costs can rise across the sector without corresponding improvements in education—and even as many institutions face declining enrollment.
It might be fine to lower credit requirements or allow high school courses to "count" for college credit as a way to reduce tuition. But I'm skeptical reducing the amount of education students receive is the right path given the structural pressures that will likely to continue to keep tuition out of reach for many students and families.