Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Cassell's avatar

Passing savings along to students is typically the last thing universities opt to do. In nearly 30 years of teaching, I’ve never seen it happen. There are many possible explanations, but two come to mind. The first concerns student representation. In Germany, student unions are directly involved, formally and informally, in debates over tuition. Efforts to increase what students pay often meet organized opposition from the very people who would bear the cost. Student unions and student governance in Germany play an actual role in university governance.

By contrast, at American universities, students often have little meaningful involvement in decisions about tuition and fees. When disputes arise over funding IT, wellness centers, study abroad programs, administrative initiatives, or additional advising, the compromise is often to add a student fee or assume future tuition increases will cover the expense. Students and parents—the people paying the bill—are rarely in the room to object. Not surprisingly, costs and fees keep rising.

The second explanation concerns inequality within higher education. Wealthy institutions with large, tax-free endowments can bid up compensation in ways that put pressure on other universities to follow. Ron Daniels, President of Hopkins and Perlioni Jason, former Hopkins CIO pull in nearly $5 million per year each. When presidents, provosts, associate provosts, and deans at the wealthiest schools receive record salaries, those salaries become benchmarks elsewhere.

The result is a kind of rising tide in compensation, driven by institutions with resources most universities cannot match. Costs can rise across the sector without corresponding improvements in education—and even as many institutions face declining enrollment.

It might be fine to lower credit requirements or allow high school courses to "count" for college credit as a way to reduce tuition. But I'm skeptical reducing the amount of education students receive is the right path given the structural pressures that will likely to continue to keep tuition out of reach for many students and families.

Ready for more?